1995 The X-Rated Critics Organization XRCO Award for Starlet of the Year (presented in 1996)[112]
1996 Hot D'Or Best New American Starlet, Best American Actress[113]
1996 AVN Best New Starlet Award, AVN Awards for Best Actress (Video) – Wicked One, Best Couples Sex Scene (Film) – Blue Movie (with T.T. Boy)[114]
1996 Fans of X-Rated Entertainment (FOXE) Video Vixen[18]
1997 AVN Award for Best Couples Sex Scene (Film) – Jenna Loves Rocco (with Rocco Siffredi), Best Couples Sex Scene (Video) – Conquest (with Vince Vouyer)[114]
1997 Hot D'Or for Best American Actress
1997 FOXE Female Fan Favorite[115]
1998 AVN Award for Best All-Girl Sex Scene (Film) – Satyr (with Missy)[114]
1998 Hot D'Or for Best American Actress – Sexe de Feu, Coeur de Glace[116]
1998 FOXE Female Fan Favorite[115]
1999 Hot D'Or for Best American Movie – Flashpoint[117]
2003 AVN Award for Best All-Girl Sex Scene (Video) – I Dream of Jenna (with Autumn and Nikita Denise)[114]
2003 G-Phoria Award for Best Female Voice Performance – Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
2003 XRCO Award for Best Girl/Girl scene – My Plaything: Jenna Jameson 2 (with Carmen Luvana) (presented August 19, 2004)[118]
2004 AVN Award for Best Interactive DVD – My Plaything: Jenna Jameson 2 (Digital Sin)[114]
2004 XRCO Hall of Fame, XRCO Award for Mainstream's Adult Media Favorite – for How to Make Love Like a Porn Star: A Cautionary Tale (tied with Seymore Butts for Family Business) (presented June 2, 2005)[119]
2005 AVN Award for Best Actress (Film) – The Masseuse, Best All-Girl Sex Scene (Film) – The Masseuse (with Savanna Samson), Best Couples Sex Scene (Film) – The Masseuse (with Justin Sterling)[120]
2006 AVN Hall of Fame, AVN Awards for Best Supporting Actress (Film) – The New Devil in Miss Jones, Best All-Girl Sex Scene (Film) – The New Devil in Miss Jones (with Savanna Samson), Crossover Star of the Year[121]
2006 F.A.M.E. Awards for Hottest Body, and Favorite Adult Actress[122]
2006 XBIZ Award Businesswoman of the Year[123]
2007 AVN Award for Crossover Star of the Year[114]
2007 F.A.M.E. Award for Favorite Performer of All Time[124]